Each article states a requirement, then the reasoning, then the test that decides whether it is met.
Cite as: Public Protocol, Art. N (2026).
An article is written so that a person who did not draft it can hold
a supplier, a government or their own institution to it. A
requirement nobody can check is a preference, so nothing appears here
without a test.
ArticleI
Sovereignty over infrastructure is a property of control. It is not established by the location of a building.
Geography is easy to relocate and easy to advertise. Authority is
neither. A system sited in one country and governed from another
has changed its address and nothing else.
TestName who holds the keys, who decides what runs, and who can be overruled.
ArticleII
A system's identity is produced by that system and held by the party operating it. No register confers it and none may withdraw it.
An identity granted by an authority can be taken by that
authority. Where identity is issued rather than held, every other
guarantee in this protocol is conditional on the issuer's
continued goodwill.
TestName the party that could revoke a participant's identity. If one exists, the article is not met.
ArticleIII
Every action on a system is decided by that system, under a policy its operator holds. A credential issued elsewhere is evidence about a party; it is never authority over a machine.
Identity services and authority are routinely conflated, and the
conflation is where remote control enters. Knowing who somebody
is settles nothing about what they may do here.
TestDoes any externally issued credential grant a permission the local policy has not already written?
ArticleIV
Stopping, powering down, isolating or erasing a system is reserved to its operator, and is conferred on no other party by any instrument.
These four powers are the difference between operating
infrastructure and hosting it. A supplier that retains any of
them retains the ability to end the service under pressure it
did not choose and cannot refuse.
TestCan any remote party stop a system on the premises? A vendor kill switch is a kill switch.
ArticleV
A system remains governable by the people present when its connection to everything else is lost.
Disconnection is the ordinary condition of a rural clinic, a
ship, a disaster response and a country under sanction. A system
that becomes unmanageable offline has made continuity a service
somebody else provides.
TestCut the uplink. Is the system still administrable by the person standing in front of it, and does the absence of the network narrow what is permitted rather than widening it?
ArticleVI
What a system declined is recorded beside what it did, and both are equally open to audit.
A record containing only actions taken cannot show restraint, and
cannot show pressure that was resisted. Refusals are the part of
the record an oversight body most needs and is least often given.
TestAsk for the refusals. A record that holds only permissions is an incomplete record.
ArticleVII
The requirements of this protocol apply to every device in a system, including those with the least capability.
Sensors, meters, cameras and controllers are the devices most
often deployed with no identity at all, and they are the origin
of the readings everything else acts on. Exempting them relocates
the weakness rather than removing it.
TestCan the smallest device sign what it reports? An unsigned sensor is an unaccountable input to every decision downstream.
ArticleVIII
A figure published about a system is measured, or is declared unmeasured. No figure is estimated into existence.
Energy, water, carbon and capacity figures are increasingly
reported under legal obligation, and an estimate filed once
becomes the baseline everything afterwards is measured against.
An absent figure is recoverable. A plausible wrong one is not.
TestFor each published figure, ask which instrument produced it. Where there is no instrument, the honest report is that there is none.
ArticleIX
A participant may leave with what is theirs, and the steps required to do so are published in advance.
Lock-in is rarely written into a contract. It accumulates in
formats, in interfaces and in the absence of anyone having tried.
A right to leave that has never been exercised is untested.
TestCount the steps to leave, and find someone who has taken them. If nobody has counted, the answer is not one.
ArticleX
Any component that asserts a property of the system — identity, integrity, authority, provenance — is published openly and may be examined independently.
A claim that cannot be inspected is a claim about the claimant's
reputation. Efficiency, convenience and intelligence may be held
privately without weakening anything this protocol requires. The
parts that make assertions may not.
TestCan an independent party read the component that makes the claim, and reproduce what it asserts?